The Middletown NJ Target shoplifting arrest began as a simple retail theft stop but quickly escalated into a multi-charge drug investigation. On October 13, 2023, police responded to a Target store in Middletown, New Jersey. They apprehended 43-year-old Marie A. Finley. She was caught trying to leave the store with a shopping cart full of unpaid merchandise. However, a routine search soon uncovered multiple bottles of powerful Schedule II narcotics hidden in her possession.
Table of Contents
Watch: Middletown NJ Target shoplifting arrest Caught on Camera
Note: Pay close attention to the timestamp at 00:07:02:09 where the situation escalates. The arresting officer questions the suspect, asking “Who’s Virginia?” after discovering prescription pill bottles under a different name.
Full Story: How the Incident Unfolded
At approximately 6:30 PM on October 13, 2023, Officer J. Mania of the Middletown Police Department made an arrest at a local Target store. The suspect, Marie A. Finley, purposefully began exiting the store with her shopping cart. The cart contained exactly $286.53 worth of merchandise. Finley had not paid for any of these items.
Because the total value of the stolen goods exceeded $200, the offense was upgraded. The officer explained to Finley that this made the theft a fourth-degree crime rather than a simple disorderly persons offense. During the stop, officers searched Finley’s belongings and found a major irregularity. They discovered two separate prescription pill bottles that did not belong to her.
Both bottles were prescribed to someone named “Virginia Finley”. The first bottle contained Hydrocodone, a highly restricted Schedule II drug. The second bottle was deceptively labeled as Amox-Clav 875-125 MG, which is a common antibiotic. However, officers found that this bottle actually contained a mix of Acetaminophen/Hydrocodone and Buspirone Hydrochloride. Finley did not have a valid prescription for any of these narcotics.
Following standard police procedure, the officer placed Finley in double-locked handcuffs. She was then placed into the back of a police cruiser to be transported to police headquarters for processing. During the ride, Finley made unusual statements to the officer. She claimed she was “walking around like a clear,” and stated that she “played and I just felt better playing”.
The Arrest: Charges Against Marie Finley
Officers formally charged Finley with four separate offenses. The initial retail theft triggered the stop, but the discovery of the pills resulted in severe drug charges.
| Charge | Simple Explanation | Potential Penalty (US) |
| 2C:20-11B(1) Shoplifting | Taking $286.53 in merchandise from Target without paying. | Fourth Degree Crime |
| 2C:35-10A(1) Possession of CDS/Analog | Knowingly possessing Hydrocodone (Schedule II) without a valid prescription. | Third Degree Crime |
| 2C:35-10A(1) Possession of CDS/Analog | Knowingly possessing Acetaminophen/Hydrocodone Bitartrate (Schedule II) without a valid prescription. | Third Degree Crime |
| 2C:35-24 Possession of Certain Prescription Drugs | Possessing two prescription bottles not belonging to her, including one mislabeled bottle. | Disorderly Persons Offense |
Legal Analysis: Was the Middletown NJ Target shoplifting arrest Justified?
Based on the police records, the Middletown NJ Target shoplifting arrest appears to follow standard constitutional guidelines. The Fourth Amendment allows police to conduct searches incident to a lawful arrest. Because Finley was legally apprehended for taking $286.53 of unpaid merchandise, officers had the right to secure her and check her belongings.
The officers strictly followed protocol during her transport. Officer Mania logged his starting vehicle mileage at 56,004.9 and his ending mileage at 56,007.5 upon arriving at headquarters. Furthermore, because the complaining witness was a law enforcement officer, a judicial probable cause determination was not required before issuing her complaint-summons.
[Read more Evidence Decode investigations here]
5 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) that are connected to the legal themes and charges in this specific case
How does the value of stolen goods affect a shoplifting charge in New Jersey?
In New Jersey, the severity of a shoplifting charge is directly tied to the total retail value of the unpaid merchandise. For example, taking merchandise valued over $200 but under $500 is generally classified as a fourth-degree crime. This carries much heavier potential penalties than stealing items valued at less than $200, which is typically considered a lesser disorderly persons offense.
What makes a medication like Hydrocodone a “Schedule II” controlled substance?
The government classifies drugs into different “schedules” based on their acceptable medical use and their potential for abuse or dependency. Schedule II drugs, such as Hydrocodone, have a high potential for abuse that can lead to severe psychological or physical dependence. Because of this, possessing them without a valid, personal prescription is treated as a serious criminal offense, specifically a third-degree crime in this jurisdiction.
Is it illegal to carry prescription medication in a bottle that does not belong to you?
Yes. It is illegal to knowingly possess prescription drugs that are not prescribed to you, or to carry them in a container belonging to someone else. Even if a bottle is mislabeled (for instance, a bottle labeled as an antibiotic but containing narcotics), carrying someone else’s prescription constitutes a disorderly persons offense.
Why are some suspects released on a “complaint-summons” instead of being held in jail?
A complaint-summons allows a defendant to be released after police processing (which includes fingerprinting and photographing) with a strict requirement to appear in court on a specific date. This is frequently used for non-violent crimes or lower-level offenses where the suspect is not considered a flight risk or a danger to the public, avoiding the need for them to wait in a jail cell to see a judge.
What happens if a defendant misses their mandatory court appearance?
When a suspect signs a complaint-summons, they agree to appear at a specific court at a designated date and time. If they fail to show up for this scheduled hearing, the judge will typically issue a warrant for their immediate arrest.
Conclusion & Current Status
Following her transport to the Middletown Police Department, officers fingerprinted and photographed Finley. Because of the nature of the charges, she was released on a complaint-summons rather than being held in jail. She was ordered to appear before the Monmouth County Superior Court in Freehold, NJ. Her mandatory court appearance was scheduled for November 15, 2023, at 8:30 AM.
Download Police Report click here.
Disclaimer: All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This report is based on official police records.
Don’t Rely on Their Word Alone In this case, conflicting stories led to an arrest. The only way to prove your innocence in a traffic stop is with your own 4K evidence. Protect yourself this holiday season. 🎄 Click Here