The Middletown NJ Hit and Run DUI Arrest of Kimberly Mancision began with a “little tap” on a bumper that quickly spiraled into a high-stakes police pursuit across the Navesink River bridge. What started as a routine Monday afternoon in Middletown, NJ, turned into a viral investigation after a 38-year-old driver allegedly fled the scene of an accident, leading officers on a chase into a neighboring town and back again.
Table of Contents
Watch: Middletown NJ Hit and Run DUI Arrest Caught on Camera
Note: Pay close attention to the timestamp at 00:18:38 where the situation escalates as the suspect repeatedly loses her balance during the “Walk and Turn” test, leading officers to stop the evaluation for her own safety.
Full Story: How the Incident Unfolded
The chaos erupted at 2:31 PM on January 23, 2025, at the intersection of Pine Street and State Route 35. A blue Toyota Prius was sitting at a stop sign when a blue Chevy Trax took a wide turn, smashing into the driver’s side.
The victim, wearing pajamas and “Chewbacca Crocs,” watched in disbelief as the Chevy Trax paused for a moment and then sped away. The victim began following the fleeing vehicle, narrating the chase to 911 dispatchers as they crossed the bridge into Red Bank.
Police caught up with the suspect vehicle, NJ license plate S21 NAR, as it re-entered Middletown. Officer Macdonald observed the vehicle swerving across lanes and immediately initiated a high-risk motor vehicle stop.
The Arrest: Charges Against Kimberly Mancision
When Officer Macdonald approached the driver, Kimberly Mancision, he noted her appearance was highly unusual. Her makeup was “in clumps all over her face,” and she had a piece of red candy stuck in her hair.
| Charge | Simple Explanation | Potential Penalty (US) |
| 39:4-50 | Driving Under the Influence (Drugs or Alcohol) | Fines, License Suspension, Jail Time |
| 39:4-88 | Failure to Maintain Lane | Fines and Points on License |
| 39:4-129 | Leaving the Scene of an Accident | Fines, Points, and Possible Jail |
| 39:3-40 | Driving While Suspended | Enhanced Fines and Extended Suspension |
Legal Analysis: Was the Middletown NJ Hit and Run DUI Arrest Justified?
Fourth Amendment Check: The stop was legally justified based on two factors: the 911 caller’s real-time report of the hit-and-run and the officer’s direct observation of the vehicle failing to maintain its lane. Under U.S. law, these “reasonable suspicions” allow police to detain a driver.
Police Protocol: Officers followed Standardized Field Sobriety Test (SFST) protocols. Interestingly, while Mancision blew a 0.00% on the Alcotest, police were still justified in the arrest.
The “clumped” makeup, droopy eyelids, slurred speech, and physical swaying provided “probable cause” that she was under the influence of a substance other than alcohol. A Drug Recognition Expert (DRE) was called in to confirm these findings.
[Read more Evidence Decode investigations here]
5 frequently asked questions (FAQs) that are connected to the charges and legal procedures in this case
Can a driver still be charged with a DUI if their BAC result is 0.00%?
Yes, a DUI charge (Statute 39:4-50) can be based on impairment from drugs, narcotics, or habit-producing substances rather than just alcohol. In this case, despite a 0.00% breathalyzer result, the officer initiated an arrest based on physical signs like slurred speech, droopy eyelids, and failing field sobriety tests.
What is the role of a Drug Recognition Expert (DRE) in a traffic stop?
A DRE is a specialized officer trained to identify impairment in drivers under the influence of drugs. When an Alcotest shows no alcohol but the driver appears impaired, a DRE performs a more detailed evaluation to determine the category of the substance involved.
What are the legal consequences of driving with a suspended license during an accident?
Driving while suspended (Statute 39:3-40) is a serious traffic offense that often carries mandatory fines and an extension of the suspension period. If an accident occurs while a license is suspended, it can lead to additional complications in court and impact the driver’s legal standing significantly.
How does “John’s Law” affect the towing and release of a vehicle?
Under John’s Law, police are required to impound a vehicle for at least 12 hours following a DUI arrest to prevent the individual from returning to the road while still impaired. The vehicle is typically towed to a secure location, and the owner is responsible for the associated fees before it can be released.
Is a urine sample required if a suspect has already provided a breath sample?
While a breath sample only measures alcohol levels, a urine sample is used to detect the presence of controlled dangerous substances (CDS) or prescription medications. If an officer suspects drug impairment, they may request a urine sample even if the alcohol test is negative.
Conclusion & Current Status
Following her arrest, Mancision was processed at Middletown Police Headquarters. Despite the 0.00% BAC, she was charged with DUI based on the suspicion of drug impairment. She later provided a urine sample for further evidence.
Mancision was released on a summons and was later transported back to her home in Long Branch by Ptl. Lanfranco the following morning. She is currently awaiting a mandatory appearance in Middletown Township Municipal Court.
Download Police Report click here.
Disclaimer: All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This report is based on official police records.
Don’t Rely on Their Word Alone In this case, conflicting stories led to an arrest. The only way to prove your innocence in a traffic stop is with your own 4K evidence. Protect yourself this holiday season. 🎄 Click Here